This hypoallergenic cardigan has mixed reviews. While some customers praised its "nice weight" and versatility as an extra layer, significant concerns emerged about quality and allergen issues. Multiple shoppers reported strong chemical smells causing allergic reactions, fabric pilling after few washes, and pocket deterioration. Sizing runs large. Positive notes include comfort when properly sized.

Weight (positive)Layer (positive)Fit (positive)Sizing (neutral)Reaction (negative)
  • 5 stars: 2 (29%)
  • 4 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 3 stars: 1 (14%)
  • 2 stars: 0 (0%)
  • 1 star: 4 (57%)
S
S.
Small / Muted Green
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Autism
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin
Deeply disappointing

The fabric was really scratchy and rough even after washing with fabric softener. Looks more like a hospital gown than a cardigan.

S
S.S.
Extra-Small / Taupe
Fit: Too large
Conditions: Allergic to polyester, spandex, nylon etc
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Allergy-Free, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Formaldehyde-Free, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Love it!

It is a bit oversized so I ordered an extra small instead of a small and I love it.

C
C.
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Mast Cell Activation Syndrome
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Others
Smells!

I don't know if it's the pink dye or what, but this had a strong chemical smell and gave me a rash! This is particularly striking because I recently got dresses from two stores that are somewhat eco friendly but not especially known for being nontoxic and both of those dresses didn't have much of a smell and also didn't give me a rash! Another Cottonique product in the same shipment didn't have the strong chemical smell so I don't think it was just contaminated during shipping. In fact, it has been quite a while since I've had such a bad reaction to a piece of clothing! I'm less sensitive than I was when I first started shopping at Cottonique so seriously stay away from at least the pink color of this!

M
M.E.
Extra-Small / Blush Pink
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: Skin sensitivity.
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Natural Organic Cotton
What made you choose Cottonique?: Sensitive Skin, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Wrinkly

I’m t wrinkles (a lot) when washed and has to be ironed.

T
T.V.

Long time loyal customer-nearly 2 decades-with anaphylaxis to latex and MCAS. Have one in pink and one in green. Material pilled after just a few washes. This is not the cotton they normally use. Both pockets -with no use and inside only wear (handful of wears) got tiny holes all over the pockets which I submitted to them with photos.

E
E.
Large / Muted Green
Fit: Too Small
Conditions: Latex allergy, multi-chemical sensitivity, MCAS
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Allergy-Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Chemical-Free, Formaldehyde-Free
What made you choose Cottonique?: Latex-Allergy, Sensitive Skin, Allergic Contact Dermatitis, Multi-Chemical Sensitivities
Cottonique items arrived reeking of strong chemical fragrances that caused an allergic reaction.

Everything in my recent Cottonique shipments smelled extremely strong like chemical fragrances and gave my family an allergic reaction. The products didn't used to arrive smelling like fabreeze/perfume/allergy causing fragrances. It was so strong we had to immediately throw it in the bin outside. I used to rely on this company for allergy safe clothing but they are now all contaminated with an allergy causing chemical fragrance. They wouldn't give me a refund on my shipment because I waited over 30 days to open it. Like many latex and MCAS allergy sufferers, opening mail is quite the ordeal and is planned ahead of time so they can all be washed together multiple times and where another person throws out the packages. I shouldn't have to pay for something we can't use and caused us an allergic reaction. We have bought from this company for many years because it was always safe. It is no longer safe and it doesn't seem like the company is doing anything to remedy this very serious issue.

M
M.N.R.
Extra-Large / Muted Green
Fit: True To Size
Conditions: none
What is the most beneficial property of Cottonique for you?: Eco-Friendly, Comfortable, Dye / Bleach Free, Latex-Free and Spandex-Free, Natural Organic Cotton, Environmental Sustainable Clothing
What made you choose Cottonique?: Comfortable, Others
Nice ash cardigan, slight soothing weight

Lovely item. Works as a bed jacket or just an extra layer. Nice weight. Wish it came in black, I'd buy one for the office, too.

"Finally, clothing your body can trust."

Woman wearing a grey Cottonique Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
Back view of a woman wearing a grey Cottonique Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
Woman wearing a beige Cottonique Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
Back view of a woman wearing a Cottonique racerback support bra in a neutral light purple tone.
Woman wearing a Cottonique Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra in beige.
Sold out
Women's Racerback Front Closure Support Bra
$72.00
Man wearing Cottonique white elasticized woven boxer shorts with button fly
Close-up of a man wearing white Cottonique: Allergy-Free Apparel elasticized woven boxer shorts.
Rear view of a man wearing white Cottonique: Allergy-Free Apparel elasticized woven boxer shorts.
Close-up of Cottonique Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts featuring wooden buttons and white fabric.
Close-up of soft, cream-colored hypoallergenic cotton fabric from Cottonique: Allergy-Free Apparel
Sold out
Men’s Elasticized Woven Boxer Shorts
$43.00
Man wearing Cottonique Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts in off-white.
Side view of a man wearing white Cottonique Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
Rear view of a man wearing Cottonique Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts in white.
Close-up of the drawstring and wooden buttons on Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts by Cottonique: Allergy-Free Apparel.
Close-up of soft, cream-colored hypoallergenic fabric from Cottonique: Allergy-Free Apparel
Sold out
Men’s Drawstring Woven Boxer Shorts
$43.00
Woman wearing a blue Cottonique 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner.
Front view of a blue organic cotton crop top bralette for sensitive skin
Back view of a blue melange organic cotton crop top with wide straps, allergy-friendly design
Woman wearing a blue Cottonique 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner.
Women's 100% Organic Cotton Rib Bra Liner
$43.00